Cryptocurrencies and Legal Protection: The Role of Exchanges in the European Regulatory Framework
The growing adoption of cryptocurrencies raises new legal challenges, particularly in cases involving theft, fraudulent transfers or disputes over ownership of digital assets. In such circumstances, obtaining a court order and ensuring its effective enforcement can be difficult, even where Italian law provides specific legal remedies.
The main challenges stem from the characteristics of blockchain transactions, which can be completed within seconds, and the international structure of the platforms responsible for managing and holding crypto-assets.
The MiCA Regulation and the Role of Exchanges
With Regulation (EU) 2023/1114, known as MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets), the European Union introduced a common regulatory framework for the issuance, trading and custody of crypto-assets. Implemented in the Italian legal system through Legislative Decree No. 129/2024, the framework strengthened authorisation, transparency and investor protection requirements, assigning specific supervisory responsibilities to the Bank of Italy and CONSOB.
A particularly important aspect concerns the role of exchanges, the platforms through which users buy, sell and hold cryptocurrencies. A distinction must be made between centralised exchanges (CEXs), operated by companies that may control private keys and transfers, and decentralised exchanges (DEXs), which rely on protocols and smart contracts and do not necessarily involve an intermediary capable of intervening in transactions.
This distinction has practical implications in the event of a dispute: while a centralised exchange may, under certain circumstances, freeze an account or prevent a withdrawal, intervening in a decentralised protocol can prove considerably more difficult.
International Exchanges and the Limits of Legal Protection
The presence of numerous international operators adds another layer of complexity. A single brand may operate through several companies established in different countries, with separate responsibilities for platform management, customer relationships and asset custody.
The company with which an Italian user has entered into a contract may therefore not be the entity actually holding the cryptocurrencies or possessing the technical means to freeze them. Before seeking judicial intervention, it is essential to identify the entity that has control over the assets and establish the jurisdiction in which it operates.
Seizure of Crypto-Assets under Italian Law
Crypto-assets may also be subject to interim measures available under Italian law. These include judicial seizure (sequestro giudiziario), governed by Article 670 of the Italian Code of Civil Procedure, in cases involving disputes over ownership or possession, and conservatory seizure (sequestro conservativo) under Article 671, which protects creditors against the risk of assets being dissipated.
Where the relevant requirements are met, Article 700 of the Italian Code of Civil Procedure may also apply. It allows parties to seek urgent interim measures to protect a right when no other suitable form of interim relief is available.
The main difficulty, however, lies in enforcing these measures. Once validated, blockchain transactions generally cannot be reversed, and assets can be transferred rapidly between different wallets and platforms. Even when blockchain analysis tools make it possible to trace cryptocurrency movements, identifying the owner of a digital wallet and recovering the transferred amounts is not always feasible.
Towards a More Effective European Framework for Legal Protection
The MiCA Regulation represents an important step towards the regulation of the crypto-asset market. However, it has not introduced a uniform European procedure for the prompt freezing of cryptocurrencies involved in disputes or for the cross-border enforcement of court orders.
The question therefore remains how to ensure effective legal protection in a market where assets can move rapidly between operators and across different jurisdictions.
One possible development could be the introduction of a European mechanism for the precautionary freezing of crypto-assets, supported by clear obligations for exchanges and custodians regarding account identification, information retention and compliance with court orders.
The challenge for European lawmakers will be to complement market regulation with equally effective judicial protection mechanisms, capable of addressing the specific characteristics of digital transactions and the international dimension of crypto-asset operators.
- Leggi l'approfondimento (ENG) (PDF, 1.24 MB)
